On December 12, 2012, I was at a diner in Hutchinson, Kansas with a beloved friend. We were just sitting down for lunch when an alert came across my phone that a man had entered Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut and murdered 20 children and six adults. I sat there in stunned silence. How could something this atrocious happen in America?
In the days and weeks that followed, there appeared two right-wing extremist ideas. The first was that the events on that dreadful day were staged. The shooter was not real, and the children did not die but were paid actors. The entire thing was a show put on to further the leftists agenda of gun control while disarming good citizens so that they could not stand against a tyrannical progressive government. The second was more sinister, that the massacre did happen, but it was perpetrated by the United States government as a way to force gun control on the populace and again, to disarm citizens in the face of despotism. Both ideas are monstrous. The first, because it pretends that those innocent children who died are still alive and thus denies the pain and sorrow felt by those who lost loved ones. The second, because it believes that our government would willingly sacrifice its most innocent citizens on the altar of gun control. The latter also foments revolution for even I would agree, a government like that must be denied its right to exist.
Both of these conspiracy theories, at their core, place the value of gun control above the value of human life. This is not to say that gun control is or is not the solution, but if our desire for firearms makes us believe that the murder of children is a hoax, then guns have become an idol.
Fortunately, the majority of American society also felt that these theories were monstrous. One of the main proponents of the first theory was Alex Jones, the host of a program called InfoWars. In 2018, Mr. Jones was sued by the families who were affected for defamation, and they won. Right-wing extremism was uncovered and called a dangerous sham.
On July 13, 2024, I came home after a long day at the Cathedral. When I opened TikTok on my phone, the first thing to appear was the video of the assassination attempt on President Trump. I was horrified and again, I sat in stunned silence. I was not alive when President Kennedy was killed, and I was too young to remember when President Reagan was shot, which makes the events of yesterday the first time in my life (at least that I can recall) that a blatant attack on the president has occurred. Like most Americans, I was glued to my media devices as more and more information came to light.
Then today, Sunday, July 14, not even 24 hours later, I have heard people claim that the attempt on the president’s life was staged. What is worse, I am aware that a member of the clergy informed their congregation that it did not really happen, it was a fake. How dare you. So, the president’s injury was not real? The innocent bystander who was murdered, is not really dead? The two people who are in critical condition should stand, take up their gurneys, and walk? The poor, deluded, and lost man who was killed by the Secret Service for trying to tear apart a country is just faking it?
Why? Why would the former president go through the trouble of faking this event? To further the right and conservative agenda? Is Trump so evil that he would fake an assassination or maybe even conspire to have real people killed to advance his political career? Of course, there are others who lament that the bullet was not an inch and a half closer. It is shameful that there are Americans who hate this man with such passion, they would revel in his death. What does this prove? It proves that the left also has extremists, and they are just as dangerous as those on the right.
Extremism is not a respecter of progressive or conservative views. In C.S. Lewis’ work The Screwtape Letters, the demon on the front lines, Wormwood, has been assigned to an Englishman during World War I. Wormwood asks his Uncle Screwtape if he should manipulate the man into become an ultra-patriot or an ultra-pacifist. What Screwtape says is telling. He says that Satan, “our father below” does not care which side the man goes too. All he cares is that the man find himself on the extreme so that his views make him lose sight of God and vilify anyone who disagrees with him.
The Devil is neither a liberal nor a conservative, a Democrat or a Republican, the Devil is an equal opportunity offender. As long as a person is so blinded by being a Democrat that he hates Republicans because they exist and as along as a Republican hates a Democrat because he breathes, that is enough for Old Scratch. Remember the words of Our Lord in the Gospel of John 10:10, “The thief does not come except to steal, and to kill, and to destroy. I have come that they may have life, and that they may have it more abundantly.”
Right-wing extremism and left-wing extremism are different sides of the same coin. Do not be fooled into believing that one is better than the other for their goal is the same, to eliminate anyone who disagrees. That is fascism, that is tyranny.
So, friends, I thank God Above that President Trump is alive, and I pray for his recovery. I am deeply saddened that a man was killed only because he was exercising his civil right to support a political candidate. I pray that the people in the hospital make a full recovery. And yes, I grieve for the soul of the young man who lost his way and paid the ultimate price for his delusions.
Let us reject extremism on both sides, let us not allow the fringe voices to tear apart a country whose torch of liberty has lit the fire of freedom for so many peoples. Let us be reminded that deep down we are neither liberals nor conservatives, Republicans or Democrats, deep down, we are Americans.
My favorite PC game in 1993 was titled Shadow President and when you exited the game, the voice of President George Bush (the first) would come through the speakers and I leave you with his words that have been seared into my brain thanks to hours dedicated to that program,
“Thank you, God bless you, and God bless the United States of America.”
Saint Paul's is a Community of Baptized Christians who are called by God to go out and make disciples of Jesus Christ.